Christ Carrying the Cross is an oil painting attributed to either Titian or Giorgione. It is dated to about 1505. The painting is housed in the Scuola Grande di San Rocco in Venice, Italy.[1] There are several later versions of the subject by Titian.
History
The painting is mentioned in several historical documents, since it has been the subject of veneration and devotion, due to its alleged miraculous properties.[2] It was originally located in the church of San Rocco, annexed to the eponymous Scuola where it is now, although it is unknown if it was on a pillar near the high altar or in a side chapel.[3]
The attribution of the work has been disputed since the 16th century: Giorgio Vasari in both the first (1550) and second (1568) edition of his Lives assigns it to Giorgione and Titian at the same time. Further, both Titian and Giorgione had a connection with the guild which held the church and the Scuola; Giorgione was a friend of painter Vincenzo Catena, a member of the guild.[4]
The composition inspired numerous painters in Veneto and Lombardy, such as Lorenzo Lotto, Giovanni Bellini and Andrea Solario.[5]
Description
Jesus is portrayed with a cross on his shoulder, against a dark background, while an executioner is holding a noose on his neck. At the side are two secondary figures. Jesus, with a doleful expression, is looking towards the seer. The profile of the executioner and of the side figures were perhaps inspired by Leonardo da Vinci's drawings, which would be part of Venetian collections at the time.[3] Although the subject of Christ Carrying the Cross had long been common for Italian art, Titian was following a type of "close-up" composition that had only recently been introduced to Northern Italy, from German or northern European examples.[6]
The painting features elements which were typical of both Titian and Giorgione: the sfumato contour of the figures and the inhomogeneous colors were common in the latter's works, while the robustness of the characters and their active participation to the event (differently than the quasi-dreaming contemplation of Giorgione) are a Titian hallmark.[7]
Versions
-
Version in the Museo del Prado,
c. 1560 (98 x 116 cm)
-
Another version in the Museo del Prado,
c. 1565 (67 x 77 cm)
-
Version in the Hermitage Museum,
c. 1565 (89 x 77 cm)
See also
References
- ^ "Christ carries the Cross". Gallery. Scuola Grande Arciconfraternita San Rocco. Archived from the original on 13 May 2014. Retrieved 28 November 2012.
- ^ Boschini, Marco (1674). Le ricche miniere della pittura veneziana.
- ^ a b Sassu, G. (2004). Giorgione. I capolavori. Milan.
{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
- ^ Storia dell'Arte. Einaudi.
- ^ Fregolent, Alessandra (2001). Giorgione. Milan: Electa. pp. 114–115. ISBN 88-8310-184-7.
- ^ Quintavalle, A.C. (15 March 1993). "Quando Tiziano voltò le spalle alla luce di Giorgione". Corriere della Sera.
- ^ Fregolent, Alessandra (2001). Giorgione. Milan: Electa. pp. 110, 114. ISBN 88-8310-184-7.
|
|---|
| Paintings |
- Detroit Trio (c. 1500) (with Titian and Sebastiano del Piombo) (disputed)
- The Three Ages of Man (c. 1500–1501)
- Portrait of Francesco Maria della Rovere (c. 1502) (disputed)
- Castelfranco Madonna (c. 1503–1504)
- Giustiniani Portrait (c. 1503–1504)
- Judith (c. 1504)
- The Test of Fire of Moses (c. 1502–1505)
- The Judgement of Solomon (c. 1502–1505)
- (c. 1505) (also attributed to Titian)
- Laura (1506)
- Il Tramonto (The Sunset) (c. 1505–1508)
- The Tempest (c. 1506–1508)
- The Three Philosophers (c. 1505–1510) (disputed)
- Adoration of the Shepherds (c. 1505–1510) (disputed)
- Portrait of a Young Man (c. 1508–1510) (disputed)
- Self-portrait as David (c. 1509–1510) (disputed)
- Self-portrait (c. 1508–1510)
- Sleeping Venus (c. 1510) (disputed)
|
|---|
| Formerly attributed | |
|---|
|
|---|
|
| Portraits |
- Jacopo Pesaro being presented by Pope Alexander VI to Saint Peter (1503–1506)
- A Man with a Quilted Sleeve (c. 1509)
- La Schiavona (1510–1512)
- A Man
- New York, c. 1512)
- (Indianapolis, c. 1515
- Shepherd with a Flute (c. 1510–1515)
- A Man in a Red Cap (c. 1510–1515)
- A Sick Man (1515)
- A Knight of Malta (c. 1515)
- Jacopo Sannazaro (c. 1514–1518)
- Gian Giacomo Bartolotti da Parma (c. 1515-1518)
- Vincenzo Mosti (c. 1520)
- Young Woman in a Black Dress (c. 1520)
- Man with a Glove (c. 1520)
- Laura Dianti (c. 1520–1525)
- Alfonso I d'Este (1523)
- A Lady (c. 1525–1565)
- Federico II Gonzaga (c. 1529)
- Giacomo di Andrea Dolfin (c. 1531–1532)
- Alfonso d'Avalos with a Page (1533)
- Charles V with a Dog (1533)
- Ippolito de' Medici (1532–1533)
- Giacomo Doria (1533–1535)
- Charles V (1533–1535)
- Isabella d'Este (1534–1536)
- La Bella (1536)
- Girl in a Fur (1536–1538)
- Count Antonio Porcia and Brugnera (c. 1535–1540)
- A Man with a Falcon (c. 1525-1537)
- Eleonora Gonzaga della Rovere (1538)
- Francesco Maria della Rovere (1536-1538)
- Cardinal Pietro Bembo (1539–1540)
- Benedetto Varchi (c. 1540)
- Pope Sixtus IV (c. 1540)
- A Young Englishman (1540–1545)
- Ranuccio Farnese (c. 1542)
- Clarissa Strozzi (1542)
- The Vendramin Family (1543–1547)
- Pietro Aretino (1545)
- Lavinia Vecellio (c. 1545)
- Pope Paul III (1545–1546)
- Pope Paul III with Camauro (1545–1546)
- Pope Paul III and His Grandsons (1545–1546)
- Cardinal Alessandro Farnese (c. 1545–1546)
- Pier Luigi Farnese (1546)
- Andrea Gritti (c. 1546–1550)
- Equestrian Portrait of Charles V (1548)
- Charles V (seated) (1548)
- Isabella of Portugal (1548)
- John Frederick I, Elector of Saxony (c. 1550–1551)
- A General (c. 1550)
- Philip II in Armour (1551)
- Cardinal Cristoforo Madruzzo (1552)
- Philip II (1554)
- Woman Holding an Apple (c. 1550–1555)
- Girl with a Platter of Fruit (c. 1555–1558)
- Fabrizio Salvaresio (1558)
- An Unknown Lady (c. 1550–1560 – also attributed to Titian's workshop)
- Jacopo Strada (1567–1568)
- A Lady in White (c. 1561)
|
|---|
| Self portraits | |
|---|
| Secular | |
|---|
| Religious |
- (c. 1505 – also attributed to Giorgione)
- Bache Madonna (c. 1508)
- Flight into Egypt (c. 1508
- Rest on the Flight into Egypt (c. 1508)
- Lochis Madonna (1508–1510)
- Saint Mark Enthroned (c. 1510)
- The Gypsy Madonna (c. 1510)
- Holy Family with a Shepherd (c. 1510)
- Christ and the Adulteress
- Glasgow, c. 1510)
- (Vienna, c. 1520
- Virgin and Child Between Saints Anthony of Padua and Roch (c. 1511)
- The Resurrected Christ (c. 1511–12)
- Baptism of Christ (c. 1512)
- Virgin and Child with Saints Stephen, Jerome and Maurice (Paris; c. 1510–1525)
- Miracle of the Jealous Husband (1511)
- Balbi Holy Conversation (c. 1513)
- Noli me tangere (c. 1514)
- The Archangel Raphael and Tobias (c. 1512–1514; c. 1540–1545)
- Salome
- Rome, c. 1515)
- (Madrid, c. 1550)
- (Private, c. 1570
- Madonna of the Cherries (1515)
- The Tribute Money (c. 1516)
- Assumption of the Virgin (1516–1518)
- The Virgin and Child with Saint George and Saint Dorothy (1516–1518)
- Virgin and Child with Saint John the Baptist and an Unidentified Saint (c. 1515–1520)
- Madonna and Child with Four Saints (c. 1516–1520)
- Pesaro Madonna (1519–1526)
- Virgin and Child with Saints Anthony Abbot, Jerome and Francis (c. 1519)
- Gozzi Altarpiece (1520)
- Virgin and Child with Saints Stephen, Jerome and Maurice (Vienna; c. 1520)
- Malchiostro Annunciation (c. 1520)
- The Entombment of Christ (c. 1520)
- Averoldi Polyptych (1520–1522)
- Saint Francis Receiving the Stigmata (1525)
- The Assassination of Saint Peter Martyr (1529)
- Aldobrandini Madonna (1530)
- Madonna of the Rabbit (1530)
- Madonna of the Roses (c. 1530)
- Penitent Magdalene (1531)
- Saint Jerome in Penitence (1531)
- Pilgrims at Emmaus (c. 1533–1534)
- Supper at Emmaus (c. 1534; c. 1545)
- The Presentation of the Virgin at the Temple (1534–1538)
- Saint John the Baptist (1540)
- Sciarra Madonna (c. 1540)
- The Crowning with Thorns (1542–43)
- Ecce Homo
- David and Goliath (c. 1542–1544)
- Abraham and Isaac (c. 1543–1544)
- Cain and Abel (c. 1543–1545)
- Serravalle Altarpiece (1548)
- Castello Roganzuolo Altarpiece (1549)
- The Fall of Man (c. 1550)
- Penitent Magdalene (c. 1550)
- Saint Jerome in Penitence (1552)
- The Martyrdom of Saint Lawrence (c. 1548–1559)
- La Gloria (1554)
- Christ Appearing to his Mother after his Resurrection (1554)
- Mater Dolorosa with Clasped Hands (c. 1555)
- Saint Jerome in Penitence (1575)
- Crucifixion (1558)
- The Entombment (1559)
- Saint Margaret and the Dragon (c. 1559)
- Annunciation (1559–1564)
- Madonna and Child with Saints Luke and Catherine of Alexandria (c. 1560)
- Penitent Magdalene (1565)
- Saint Dominic (c. 1565)
- Judith with the Head of Holofernes (c. 1570)
- Religion saved by Spain (1572–1575)
- Saint Sebastian (c. 1575)
- The Crowning with Thorns (1576)
- Pietà (1576)
|
|---|
| Museums |
- Casa natale di Tiziano Vecellio
|
|---|
| Related |
- Orazio Vecellio (son)
- Francesco Vecellio (brother)
- Cesare Vecellio (cousin)
- Marco Vecellio (nephew)
- Girolamo di Tiziano (disciple)
- Titian (crater)
|
|---|